Ice Cream Cakes & Pies
Each ice cream cake & pie is handmade at Merla Mae. Choose from our everyday favorites or custom-made to your match taste preference and style.
Ice cream cakes tailored for you
Portrait Cakes
A perfect gift for any occasion.
Bring in or email us your favorite photo and we will scan and print it on special edible paper. Just choose the size and flavor, and a stunning photo cake will be made fresh for your desired date.
Custom Shaped Cakes
Ice cream cakes with a unique look.
We have tons of cake molds and shapes. From cartoon character favorites, all the way to princesses and sports-related molds.
Seasonal Specialties
Delicious festive cakes & pies.
From Easter bunnies, Hearts, Christmas trees, or Santa himself. Our design specialists will make you the perfect cake.
Birthday Cakes
Happy birthday never tasted so good.
Balloons or flowers, sprinkles or chocolate, red or blue; the choice is yours, and with tons of choices, we’ll make sure your birthday cake is perfect.
We have your favorite flavors
Delicious and fresh, original ice cream cakes and pies, pick one up in seconds or order your own custom-made flavor. Just give us between 1 to 2 days and it will be perfect.
Choose from Merla-Mae’s original ice cream recipe (a thick layer of real vanilla ice cream and a delicious fudge and crunch center, finished off with real chocolate ice cream.)
Our pies have a choice of Oreo® or Graham Cracker Crust.
If our original recipe doesn’t cut it, pick your favorite flavors like Oreo®, Caramilk®, Skor®, Oh Henry®, Snickers®, Smarties®, Crispy Crunch®, Turtles®, Reese’s Pieces®, Pecan Brownie, Banana Royale, Banana Split, Fudge Crunch, Caramel Crumble, Grasshopper, French Mint, Butterscotch Ripple, Avalanche, Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough, Pumpkin, Assorted Cheesecake, Caramel Cashew, Pralines’n Crème, Toasted Coconut, Verry Berry, Mocha Almond, Rocky Road, Apple Dandy, Amaretto, Decadent Fudge, Mint Chocolate Chip, Mint Oreo,… you get the point, let us know your favorite flavors and we will make it happen!
Merla-Mae has the flavors, and each and every option is wonderfully delicious. We also carry peanut-free allergy ice cream cakes and gluten-free ice cream cakes.
Choose your size
Serving Sizes Starting from 4 People, all the way to 60+!
Can’t decide? Visit us in-store, our cake experts will be more than happy to help guide you and show you some examples.